Why buying climbing shoes is better than renting

Bouldering is pretty straightforward as a sport but it’s not exactly running either. That means that unless you’re Charles Albert – the barefoot climber you have to wear climbing shoes for indoor bouldering.

If you are a beginner, however, it’s not always easy to know when it’s time to invest in personal climbing shoes. And the more bouldering gets in your system the sooner you’ll start wondering: Is it time to buy my pair?

From financial aspects, and performance to long-term benefits, this article aims to help you make an informed decision. After all, whether you’re sending your first V2 problem or still mastering the basics, climbing shoes can significantly boost your climbing experience.

Why is buying climbing shoes better than renting?

Some time ago I went to the climbing gym just to realise I had forgotten my climbing shoes. I wouldn’t give up my training session because of that so I rented a pair.

What did I learn from this experience?

1. Having climbing shoes is better than none.
2. Always remember to take your climbing shoes.

Nothing compares to having your own climbing shoes that you love and trust. Your climbing experience is just so much better! Here’s why:

Because of hygiene and health considerations

It’s no secret that rental shoes are used by many climbers. This can turn them into a breeding ground for bacteria, especially fungal skin infections (athlete’s foot). Wearing your own pair of shoes makes this concern go away.

To be on the safe side, consider wearing climbing socks when wearing rental climbing shoes.

You pay less money in the long term

Buying climbing shoes can seem like a big deal when you pay them upfront. However, if you do the math on rental costs, after just 3-4 months of regular climbing, they typically exceed the price of a new entry-level pair of climbing shoes.

Therefore, if you are planning to climb at least once or twice a week, it’s worth it!

It’s a good long-term investment

Entry-level shoes often last beginners 12-18 months before resoling. Depending on various aspects such as the type of sole and provider, the price to resole a pair of climbing shoes varies between £30 and £50. Not to mention you can resell your shoes if they’re still in good shape.

You’ll be able to have bouldering projects outdoors

Not having your own climbing shoes also means you’re not going to be able to experiment with how climbing on rock feels. Having your pair gives you the freedom to climb outside.

You’ll enjoy a better fit and comfort

Rental shoes usually come in standard sizes and shapes and are often stretched out from frequent use. This can result in a poor experience. When you buy your own climbing shoes, you can choose a pair that fits your feet perfectly and adapts gradually.

Improved performance

A well-fitting shoe provides better precision and holds a better grip as well as sensitivity on the wall. Rental shoes are made to last, not to perform; therefore, they are often worn out, and have less sticky rubber.

You can have your personal style

Just because you are a beginner you can’t choose shoes that align with the latest climbing trends. Who says that? Marketing exists for a reason: we all have preferences.

It helps you improve your technique

In time, you’ll come to trust your climbing shoes because you’ll be using the same pair consistently. This will allow you to focus on improving your foot technique and even tackle challenging boulder problems!

What to keep in mind when buying your first climbing shoes

POV: You are a beginner, and after reading this article, you decided to go on and purchase your first pair of climbing shoes. Yay! In this case, here’s our final advice you might want to consider to make your best choice.

Try before buying

Finding the right climbing shoes can be a bit of a challenge, especially since everyone’s feet are different. That’s why it is best for you to test multiple models and sizes.

You can do this at climbing shops or during climbing festivals, where brands often have test models available. This allows you to test the shoes for an entire day and decide if they suit you. If you can’t decide after only one day, no one is pressuring you to. You can always buy the model online.

Boulderflash offers a great selection of climbing shoes, perfect for both indoor and outdoor bouldering, as well as sports climbing.

Prioritise comfort

It’s not that more advanced shoes are often painfully tight, but they sure feel like it to beginners who are not used to climbing. Therefore, despite what other people might tell you (climbing must hurt) remember to value comfort over so-called performance just so you can enjoy longer bouldering sessions. Otherwise, you will start hating climbing before you even start properly.

Here’s a guide we wrote on how tight your climbing shoes should be and how to fit them.

Consider versatility

As a beginner, you will discover a lot: from climbing styles to types of shoes. So, consider buying an all-around first pair rather than highly specialized models. By the time you learn to make all the difference, you’ll be able to climb comfortably, and, most importantly, you’ll enjoy it!

Budget-friendly

In the first year, it doesn’t really make sense to pay that much for your first pair of shoes. It will not make any difference, as more expensive models often benefit only more advanced climbers. Entry-level shoes offer the best value for beginners’ performance.

In our Boulderflash shop, you can find a pretty interesting offer on entry-level shoes with moderate design.

What is a beginner’s climbing shoe?

A beginner climbing shoe is designed to provide comfort, durability, and support while helping new climbers develop proper technique. Unlike aggressive, high-performance shoes, shoes for beginners tend to be more comfortable and have a looser fit.

Should climbing shoes hurt?

Key features of beginner climbing shoes

• Flat or slightly downturned shape – reduces foot strain and allows all-day wear
• Loose fit – less toe compression for added comfort
• Thicker rubber sole – more durable and forgiving while learning foot placement and developing muscles
• Velcro or lace closure – easy to put on, adjust, and remove
• Affordable price – budget-friendly options to start climbing without a big investment

Climbing shoes that are recommended for beginners

Your first climbing shoes should be some you can wear all day long in full comfort. Ideally, you can adjust them to your foot’s shape. For that reason, shoes with lace-ups or velcro closure systems are great!

Here’s our top 5 bouldering shoes for beginners

Boreal Alpha

The Boreal Alpha is a natural choice for beginners and those seeking a comfortable yet capable climbing shoe. Thanks to a soft microfiber upper and double-strap closure, it provides a snug, adjustable fit. The Cushioned Heel System (CHS) adds comfort, while the anti-deformation midsole offers stability and flexibility for better sensitivity on footholds.

Equipped with Zenith Quattro 2.0 rubber, the Alpha delivers a durable grip for indoor and outdoor climbs. Its semi-symmetrical design allows for a relaxed or precise fit, making it perfect for long sessions and multi-pitch routes. A versatile and reliable choice for progressing climbers!

Evolv V6

The Evolv V6 is a top choice for beginners looking to improve quickly and climb harder grades without discomfort. Designed to be easily adjusted and fit snugly, it helps you transition smoothly between climbs.

Thanks to its TRAX SAS rubber and a downturned toe, the V6 offers excellent grip and precision, making it great for steep climbs and small footholds. It also features a large toe patch for toe hooking and a Shaman love bump midsole for comfort and power on small holds. Plus, it’s 100% vegan, making it a great option for those with a vegan lifestyle.

If you want to know more about Evolv, its history, and its best shoes, then check out our guide here.

Red Chilli Circuit

With beginner climbers in mind, the Red Chili Circuit combines incredible comfort with the challenges of modern climbing. Affordable yet durable climbing shoe for all-day comfort, the Circuit provides optimal space for toes and a slightly muted downturn that supports you perfectly on holds. Ideal for multi-pitch climbs and long training sessions.

Tenaya Tanta

The Tenaya Tanta is designed for comfort, versatility, and impressive performance. An excellent option for beginners transitioning to intermediate climbing, it comes with a slightly curved last and a moderately downturned toe box, which provides better foot placement on small holds, helping new climbers develop precision and technique.

Additionally, the Tanta borrows features from high-end models such as M4 technology for foot sensitivity while remaining affordable, making it a budget-friendly yet high-performing shoe.

When rentals instead of buying climbing shoes make sense

1. You climb on occasion: If you climb less than once monthly, rentals may be more economical.
2. You are not ready to commit: To some, the first 2-3 sessions might be too early to determine your interest level.
3. Growing feet: For younger climbers such as children whose shoe size is still changing rapidly.

Should you or should you not buy climbing shoes as a beginner?

Don’t get me wrong! If you’re just dipping your toes into the world of climbing, rental shoes are a great starting point! However, once you understand there’s no way back it’s time for you to invest in your own pair. I guarantee that having your own climbing shoes not only improves your climbing experience but also your performance.

Moreover, having new, perfectly fitting climbing shoes might even motivate you to try hard and give you the confidence to pursue bouldering problems. If you plan to climb regularly and want better comfort, performance, and hygiene, it makes all the sense in the world.

Be sure to check out our selection of climbing shoes in our shop and make your best choice!

Products related to this article